Ty’s death was devastating! Now, hearing rumors about the possibility of Amy or Jack passing away feels like it could be the end of the series. Sure, Jack can’t live forever, but the show has so much potential to continue for years, especially with the younger generation growing up. If Ty hadn’t left, he could have easily stepped into Jack’s role, guiding the family. They could have made Amy and Ty’s baby a boy, or started Season 14 with Amy discovering she was pregnant with a son after Ty’s death. This would have opened up countless new storylines. Unfortunately, the writers limited their options by choosing to have only daughters in the family.
I just finished binge-watching from Season 1, Episode 1, all the way to Season 16, Episode 10, and kept expecting a boy to join the family, but it never happened! If Jack dies, Heartland will too!
As dedicated viewers, we can’t handle another major death. Ty’s passing was heartbreaking—I cried through the whole episode and seriously considered stopping watching. Why would they do that, especially with such a central character? The show was about Ty and Amy, and we loved them both, along with all the other characters. In my opinion, it was a huge mistake by the producers to kill off Ty. I was once a massive Grey’s Anatomy fan, but when Derek died, I stopped watching; he was a main character and a big part of the story, just like Ty and Amy. Now, I’m still deciding whether to keep watching Heartland. I wish they could go back and undo that mistake—I’m sure they’ve lost a lot of viewers because of it.
